Wade Mathews is slowly coming to when he finds 'Psycho Joe' (Mickey Taylor) has him and Gabriel Phoenix tied up with their mouths taped shut. Joe threatens them both with a large kitchen knife and warns them not to talk while professing his love for Leo Rex. Joe tells the bound studs that whoever he enjoys more, gets to live. He starts taking advantage of his hostages, burying his face in their crotches before pulling Wade's pants down and sucking his cock. After Joe has his taste of Wade, he turns back to the Gabriel to suck his thick dick. As part of his sick game, Joe unties Gabriel and instructs him to get on his knees and service Wade's cock. Eager not to die, the two do as they're told and switch places so Wade can suck on Gabriel's dick. Joe keeps teasing them both with his knife, reassuring them that he's in charge. As the boys compete to impress Joe and stay alive, the Psycho stands up to feed Gabriel his cock. After they all take turns blowing each other, Joe gets down to plant his tongue in between Wade's crack to prepare him for what's to come. While Wade keeps sucking Gabriel's meat, Joe works his thick pole into Wade's tight hole. Joe wants to watch Gabriel fuck Wade, so they switch positions, keeping Wade in the middle. Joe isn't done with them yet as he gets on all fours to take a pounding from Gabriel as he wraps his lips around Wade's cock. Now it's Wade's turn to fuck his captor as Joe sucks down the pole that was just inside of him. Gabriel is eager to feel a tight ass one more time and he shoves his cock back into Joe. While Gabriel is pounding Joe, Wade jerks his load onto Joe's ass. Wade pulls out and adds his load to the mix before eating both loads out of Joe's crack. The hostages get on their knees one last time to let Joe stroke out his load all over their faces. In the end, who fucked Joe better? Will 'Psycho Joe' let them both live or die?